Jump to content

In-App Album ReplayGain Editor


Recommended Posts

ReplayGain is essential to my listening experience because, for no good reasons, the Loudness War is still a thing. Unfortunately, ReplayGain scanners, though better than nothing, are never perfect. Varying dynamic range levels can trip them up, and it doesn't really make sense to normalize the loudness of, say, a death metal album and an ambient synth album. Typically, these error margins are acceptable because it usually only takes a few seconds of listening and a few volume level adjustments to find the sweet spot. However, this isn't always the case. One of my all-time favorite albums is raison d'être's Mise en Abyme (2014). This is a dark ambient album whose first track is a 12-minute slow build. Here, the error margins of the ReplayGain scanner aren't acceptable. I want to set the volume at the outset and know that the climax 10-ish minutes in is going to be at the right volume. Thankfully, the album is mastered at the K-14 level, so I can turn off ReplayGain, set the volume at the level that the ReplayGain scanner seems to approximate (70% in Poweramp with DVC enabled with my Hiby R5 and Campfire Audio Andromeda's), and listen away.

Obviously, not every album is mastered at K-14. But I would still like my ReplayGain to be more accurate so I don't have to adjust the volume level. To this end, I have discovered that, at least with my setup, 1% on the volume knob is equal to 1 dB. So, if I listen to an album (without a ReplayGain tag) and the comfortable listening volume level is 62%, I'll edit the ReplayGain tag to -8.00 dB to match the 70% of the K-14 level mastered albums. I do this in Yate (on Mac), but then I have to delete and re-upload the files onto my DAP. It would be very helpful if I could edit the album ReplayGain tag in the app to effectively bake-in the volume level without having to reconnect my DAP to my computer.

Edited by EthelTheFrog
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...